Last Updated on January 14, 2021 by Lynda Stevens
We’ve all been in a situation where we thought a toilet paper holder wasn’t important, but then something goes wrong. Maybe the toilet paper roll is too big and won’t fit correctly. Maybe the holder is made of flimsy materials and keeps falling down when someone tries to take a few sheets. Whatever the situation, we learn fast that we deserve the best toilet paper holder.
In this review, we examine five separate toilet paper holders and identified the one with the highest quality. The majority of these toilet paper holders are the freestanding variety. This means the holder does not need to be attached to a wall or sink to remain upright. One product, the Moen, was popular enough to warrant mention despite being a traditional wall-hanging toilet paper holder. So, what do we look for? In general, a good toilet paper holder is capable of completing its job. This means it holds rolls without falling down and is sturdy and durable enough to last through years of constant use. After all, the bathroom sees more visits than many other rooms in the standard apartment or house. After looking at tons of information, here are the toilet paper holders we found to be the best.
Best Toilet Paper Holder Reviews
- AmazonBasics Freestanding Toilet Paper Stand with Reserve
- Simple Houseware Bathroom Toilet Paper Roll Holder
- Moen DN8408CH Preston Toilet Paper Holder
- mDesign Freestanding Metal Wire Toilet Paper Holder
- TomCare Toilet Paper Holder
1. AmazonBasics Freestanding Toilet Paper Stand with Reserve
Dimensions: 6.5 (L) x 7 (W) x 27.5 (H) in.
Weight: 3.5 lbs.
The AmazonBasics Freestanding Toilet Paper Stand with Reserve is a tall, reliable stand that can be moved around and even has a warranty, which is great for people who like a little extra protection for their purchases.
Our top choice is awarded to the AmazonBasics Freestanding Toilet Paper Stand with Reserve, shortened to the AmazonBasics Toilet Paper Stand. This toilet paper holder is a metallic piece designed to stand upright. It has a weighted base to stop it from tipping over from the weight of toilet paper rolls and also includes an extra vertical bar to store reserve rolls. Based on its dimensions, the vertical bar can hold up to four rolls while an additional fifth one fits on an upper horizontal bar for use. AmazonBasics sells the holder with a 1-year limited warranty that covers damage during regular use, so it’s possible to replace the toilet paper holder if something goes wrong.
The AmazonBasics Toilet Paper Stand is one of the easiest to clean since dirt and dust come away with a damp cloth. The finish is designed to prevent rusting and corrosion, common problems in bathrooms. A single holder costs between $25 and $30 and is plated in nickel. It is not available in other colors.
Although simple, the AmazonBasics toilet paper holder is the best one out of the five reviewed here since it meets several crucial criteria. It stands up on its own without any reserves necessary, it is easy to clean, and it even comes with a warranty. How many toilet paper holders can say that? As we discovered, very few.
If there is anything that is a detriment to the AmazonBasics Toilet Paper Stand, it’s that the design is plain. The holder does not feature a basket or cylinder design, meaning it just looks like several polished bars welded together. It is also available in only a single color – silver – which can be annoying for individuals who like to style their bathrooms. However, the actual reliability of the product is solid, and it remains upright, an important feature in any holder.
2. Simple Houseware Bathroom Toilet Paper Roll Holder
Full Product Dimensions: 7.2 (L) x 7.2 (W) x 23.5 (H) in.
Space Organizer Dimensions: 5 (L) x 5 (W) in.
Weight: 1.8 lbs.
The Simple Houseware Bathroom Toilet Paper Roll Holder is definitely designed to be space saving, so it works well for individuals in small homes or apartments who want to maximize their limited area.
The Simple Houseware Bathroom Toilet Paper Roll Holder is a reliable toilet paper repository that functions as a freestanding holder. It features one horizontal bar for dispensing and then an open cylinder to store extra unused rolls. Based on the product’s dimensions, the cylinder holds about three average-sized rolls, an amazing feature for those who always want extra available should they run out.
The holder is available in two colors. The finish is chrome or bronze but the interior material remains a mystery. A space organizer is included at the bottom, which is great for storing extra materials. This space organizer is the perfect size for extra washcloths, reading material, or other bathroom products.
In general, the Simple Houseware Bathroom Toilet Paper Roll Holder is reliable and durable. The finish is rustproof and the entire design is meant to be space-saving, so it works well in even the smallest of bathrooms. The holder can be cleaned with a damp cloth.
The only major issue is that the bottom is not weighted, and many users found that the stand will fall over if not enough rolls of toilet paper are left in the bottom reservoir. For this reason, it is not one of our best holders but remains a great option for individuals on a budget. The average price is between $18 and $22.
3. Moen DN8408CH Preston Toilet Paper Holder
Dimensions: 12.3 (L) x 4.1 (W) x 2.7 (H) in.
Weight: 12 oz.
The Moen DN8408CH Preston Toilet Paper Holder is an attachable holder great for people who definitely have little bathroom space and want something they can screw in place and keep out of the way.
The Moen DN8408CH Preston Toilet Paper Holder is different from the other products reviewed here because it is not freestanding. Instead, it is a classic toilet paper holder that needs to be screwed into a wall or wooden or plywood sink. This method of toilet paper holding is far more flexible than a standing holder because it can be placed in a variety of positions but also can be used to hold other materials like towels. This isn’t the original purpose, but many users found they liked buying multiple to tie together the look of a bathroom.
The Moen DN8408CH Preston Toilet Paper Holder is available in two colors: chrome and brushed nickel. The holder is made of zinc and the finish is chrome. The finish is designed to be durable and resistant to corrosion and rust, problems that often plague metal implements in the bathroom. The toilet paper holder comes with the Moen’s Limited Warranty, which means the manufacturer will cover any part defects and damages not caused by user error or the use of abrasive cleaners. Each one costs between $8 and $12.
The pros of the Moen DN8408CH Preston Toilet Paper Holder are that it fits the roll perfectly, makes it easy for users to slide a roll on and off of the main hook, and features a simple design. It is also reliable and sturdy and can be cleaned with a damp cloth without any trouble.
The main con of this toilet paper holder is that it can be difficult to install because of some slight fitting issues. The screws that accompany the holder do not properly fit their settings, which can make it hard for buyers to install the holder without making some adjustments or jamming the screws into place. Once installed, it is also difficult to remove the holder and place it in another location.
4. mDesign Freestanding Metal Wire Toilet Paper Holder
Full Product Dimensions: 7.5 (L) x 5.25 (W) x 23 (H) in.
Top Shelf Dimensions: 4.5 x 6.5 in.
Weight: 3 lbs.
The mDesign Freestanding Metal Wire Toilet Paper Holder is for those with a creative spirit who want to add a little extra color and pop to their bathroom.
The mDesign Freestanding Metal Wire Toilet Paper Holder, besides having a long name, is a reasonable sized standing toilet paper holder that works well in most bathrooms. It includes some extra features like a toilet paper roll open storage cylinder, a raised base, and numerous colors and patterns for the buyer to choose from. A horizontal rod is used for toilet paper dispensing, and the cylinder is large enough to hold two extra rolls. A top shelf is positioned above the horizontal dispensary and can be used to store small goods like cell phones and books for reading.
The raised base on the mDesign is sturdy and weighted to prevent the holder from tipping over. The entire holder is made of strong steel wire and features a rust-resistant finish to stop corrosion from all of the water vapor and humidity found in bathrooms. The holder requires some assembly but arrives in two pieces and comes with instructions. Because of the finish, the holder can be wiped clean with a damp cloth.
Unlike other toilet paper holders that tend to only be available in two or three finishes, the mDesign features a whopping seven designs in a variety of metallic and matte options. These are satin, bronze, chrome, matte black, matte white, rose gold, and soft brass. The product costs between $18 and $22.
While the mDesign toilet paper holder comes in numerous colors, it is difficult to keep standing because the bottom is not weighted enough. For this reason, it is not one of the best.
5. TomCare Toilet Paper Holder
Dimensions: 6.9 (L) x 6.8 (W) x 13.8 (H) in.
Weight: 2.45 lbs.
The TomCare Toilet Paper Holder is an elegant product that works well for those who want to include storage and get some money back should something go wrong.
The TomCare Toilet Paper Holder is a standing toilet paper holder designed to serve three purposes. It can be used as a single roll dispenser, a storage tower, and features an extra attached shelf for the additional storage of small objects like a cell phone or book. The freestanding design is elegant and features an enclosed storage area for rolls of unused toilet paper. The structure is made of reinforced and strengthened brown metal and is designed to be rust-proof and resistant to damage while still being lightweight.
No tools are required to assemble the TomCare Toilet Paper Holder, which comes in several pieces. Instead, each individual portion clips together to the others. The manufacturer of the TomCare Toilet Paper Holder offers a 45-day money back guarantee and a 12-month warranty with each purchase. The customer service line handles warranty requests promptly. The product costs between $25 and $30.
The TomCare Toilet Paper Holder can be cleaned with a damp cloth but buyers should avoid using caustic or corrosive cleaning chemicals on the finish.
In general, the TomCare Toilet Paper Holder is reliable and easy to install but suffers from being short. It can be difficult to reach the roll of toilet paper and is rather flimsy. For these reasons, it is not one of the best despite being attractive.
Out of these products, the best toilet paper holder is the AmazonBasics Freestanding Toilet Paper Stand with Reserve. Although it has a long name, the AmazonBasics toilet paper holder is one of the sturdiest and most durable freestanding holders currently on the market. Besides durability, a toilet paper holder needs to be attractive. Part of why the AmazonBasics Freestanding Toilet Paper Stand with Reserve is the best holder is because its simplistic design and shiny finish is pleasing to the eye and works with most bathrooms. It won’t clash or stand out too much, but it also holds its own by being capable of remaining upright without needing any rolls to be stored in reserve.
Choose the right accessories for your bathroom by reading our bathroom essentials guide today!
Choosing a toilet paper holder seems simple, but there are a few factors to consider when finding the best one.
First, know the dimensions of the bathroom where it will be located. For apartments and small homes, sometimes there isn’t room to place a freestanding holder. In these cases, one that can be installed to the wall is the best choice.
Second, choose one that is durable and able to withstand the rigors of the bathroom. Bathrooms are prone to high humidity, various temperature changes, and other atmospheric fluctuations. The best toilet paper holder is going to be one with a clean finish that prevents rust and other corrosion.
Can It Be Cleaned?
Third, find a toilet paper holder that is easy to clean. Bathrooms are already difficult to keep free of problems like soap scum, algae, and mold. A toilet paper holder should be the last thing suffering from issues of uncleanliness. The best ones are products that can be wiped clean with a damp washcloth to remove dust and debris. An easily disinfected holder is also a great option for bathrooms frequented by small children.
Now that you know what to look for in a toilet paper holder, it’s time to find the product of your wildest dreams! You can learn more about the particular products recommended here by clicking on the links to view each toilet paper holder. You can also check out our homepage and website to get more reviews, recommendations, and lifestyle tips.