The Best Toilets Under $200: Our Affordable Picks For Homeowners

Updated by Lynda Stevens

You know as well as we do how important having a good toilet is. A toilet that is comfortable to sit on, a toilet that flushes properly, a toilet that will make your bathroom proud. It’s especially hard to find a good toilet if you’re on a tight budget, as you may have some concerns about the quality. To give your toosh the high-end treatment that it deserves, we’ve selected the best toilets under $200, so that you can find the best deal for your budget.

The best toilets for under $200 are durable, comfortable, effective and water-efficient at the same time. We wanted to make sure that your new toilet won’t only be affordable upon purchase, but over time as well! In order to prepare you to make the best choice for your unique needs and preferences, we also prepared a useful buying guide at the end of the article, where we share the most important factors you should consider when choosing your new toilet.

PictureProductPriceWarrantyToilet Bowl Shape
Toto Eco Drake$$1-year limited warrantyElongated
Mansfield Plumbing 135.160.WHT$$$Limited lifetime warranty on china; One-year limited warranty on tank trimRound
American Standard H2Optimum Siphonic$Limited Lifetime Warranty on chinaware. Limited 5-year warranty on all mechanical partsRound
PictureProductPriceWarrantyToilet Bowl Shape

1.  Toto Eco Drake : Best for Most People

Click for Price

“This toilet provides a powerful flush that wastes less water than most toilet tanks!”

The Toto Eco Drake is our top choice for most people because it’s affordable, comfortable, and eco-friendly. This two-piece toilet provides a powerful flush that wastes less water than most toilet tanks, so if you’re looking for a long-term economical toilet, you’ll certainly enjoy the reduced water bills with this option. Considering this toilet’s quality and durability, it offers great value for your money. Toto, we’re not in Kansas anymore.

Pros:

One of our favorite things about the Toto Eco Drake is that it’s effective and water-efficient at the same time. It features E-Max flushing technology, which provides a powerful and clean flush while only using only 1.28 GPF (gallons per flush). Thanks to its eco-friendliness, the Toto is WaterSense, CALGreen, and CEC certified. 

As most older toilet models spend about 1.6 GPF, switching them out for a model like the Toto can reduce water usage by 20-35%, which adds up to about 13,000 gallons of water per year. This makes the Toto a choice good for both your wallet and the environment!

“In addition to reducing your water bills, the Toto comes at a very affordable price at purchase.”

In addition to reducing your water bills, the Toto comes at a very affordable price at purchase, costing well below $200. The Toto comes in several different color options, but this price is applicable for the colonial white – the other color options (bone, ebony, beige, etc.) are more expensive (you can check out the different prices on the Amazon page).

The design of the Toto is quite ergonomic. The elongated front bowl will provide you with enough space for comfortable sitting, without physical contact with the back end of the bowl. The large trapway is designed to further ensure a clean flush. Plus, this toilet is ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act) compliant, making it a good choice for people with physical limitations.

Additional, the Toto is easy to maintain. The ceramic is fully glazed, which will allow for easy cleanup.

This model is durable enough for both residential and commercial applications. It comes with a 1-year limited warranty, which may not seem like much, but in this price range, it’s quite difficult to find anything with a longer warranty.

The toilet is computer-designed to feature clean lines and curves, which make it a classical and straightforward aesthetic choice for your bathroom. 

The Toto offers good value for your money thanks to the equipment included in the purchase. In addition to the 3-inch flush valve, toilet bowl, and tank set, you also get a tank to bowl gasket, tank to bowl hardware, and toilet bolt caps.

Cons:

One of the drawbacks of this purchase is that the toilet seat is not included – although this is the case with most toilet options under $200. You’d also need to purchase the wax ring, toilet mounting bolts, and water supply lines separately.

Another thing to keep in mind is that since the flushing mechanism is designed to waste less water, if you hold the handle down for less than 3 seconds, it will only half-flush. Hold it longer for a full flush!

2.  Mansfield Plumbing 135.160.WHT : Best On A Budget

Click for Price

“For about $100, you get a comfortable toilet that offers a clean flush!”

The Mansfield Plumbing 135.160.WHT is the cheapest of the cheap, but none the worse for it. For about $100, you get a comfortable toilet that offers a clean flush and comes with an incredible limited lifetime warranty on the china. If you’re pressed for money, go for the Mansfield! It won’t disappoint.

Pros:

This two-piece toilet is quite a durable option for the money. As we already mentioned, the high-quality vitreous china is warrantied for life! You don’t ever see that sort of a warranty in this price range. The tank trim, on the other hand, is warrantied for 1 year only, but it’s still a great warranty for the price.

“The high-quality vitreous china is warrantied for life!”

The Mansfield is a pretty comfortable toilet option. It features an elongated front, which provides enough space for comfortable sitting. The 15-inch bowl height puts this toilet on the mid-low height range, which makes it a good choice for people with bowel difficulties.

Although it’s not as water-efficient as the Toto, the Mansfield provides a very powerful flush. Especially for users who get frustrated by eco-friendly toilets, the Toto is a great choice. It uses 1.6 GPF and features a 2-inch glazed trap way, ensuring a clean flush every time! 

The Mansfield is also easy to install. The purchase comes with a smart fasten tank-to-bowl connection which uses only 3 bolts. Plus, the ballcock valve is included with the product!

Last but not least, the Mansfield features an elegant and simple design. It’s a great choice for bathrooms where the sink and shower/bathtub are in white.

Cons:

The Mansfield uses more water for each flush than other toilet options on this list.

Additionally, as is the case with other cheap models, you’d need to purchase the toilet seat and the water supply lines separately.

3.  American Standard H2Optimum Siphonic : Best Value For Money

Click for Price

“This toilet offers the best warranty and lowest water-consumption on this list!”

The American Standard H2Optimum Siphonic is eco-friendly, cheap, and very durable. For about $130, this toilet offers the best warranty and lowest water-consumption on this list. Since it features a round rather than an elongated bowl, we especially recommend the American Standard for smaller bathrooms.

Pros:

This toilet is the most water-efficient option on our list. It’s WaterSense certified and uses 1.1 GPF – good for nature, good for your wallet. At the same time, the featured H2Optimum siphon jet bowl technology doesn’t sacrifice performance, so you can expect a clean, frustration-free flush.

The American Standard is a great choice for smaller bathrooms. Although round toilet bowls may not provide as much sitting space as elongated toilet bowls, they are very space-efficient. 

Plus, the American Standard is quite stylish. The round bowl and simple curves give this toilet a good look!

“The American Standard is a great choice for smaller bathrooms.”

The additional features that accompany the American Standard toilet really add value for your money. For instance, the toilet includes an EverClean surface, which inhibits the growth of odor-causing bacteria, mold, and mildew, prevents permanent staining, and makes it really easy to clean.

Last but not least, this toilet is a highly durable option. American Standard offers a limited lifetime Warranty on the china, and a limited 5-year warranty on all mechanical parts. This is, by far, the best warranty available on the market – for products in its price range and beyond!

Cons: 

As with the other options on this list, this purchase comes without a toilet seat and water supplies lines.

As the American Standard is a round toilet bowl, it doesn’t provide as much space for comfortable sitting as other options. While it’s good for smaller bathrooms, some users have found this option to be too small for their liking.

Conclusion

The Toto Eco Drake is the best choice for most people as it combines comfort and water-efficiency at an affordable price. The elongated bowl and height of this toilet provide more comfort while sitting, and also make the Toto ADA compliant. The 1.28 GPF value will cut water bills and reduce water waste. If you’re looking for a toilet that will be economical in the long run, the Toto won’t disappoint.

Our cheapest recommendation is the Mansfield Plumbing 135.160.WHT. Although this option is cheap, it doesn’t sacrifice performance. For only $100, this durable toilet comes with a 1-year warranty on the tank trim, and a lifetime warranty on the chinaware – a gem in the world of cheap toilets. While the Mansfield uses more water than the other options – with 1.6 GPF – it promises a cleaner flush than any of the alternatives. If you’re on a tight budget or if you want to always be sure that the bowl will be clean after a single flush, you should consider getting the Mansfield.

The American Standard H2Optimum Siphonic offers the best value for your money as it’s the most eco-friendly and durable option on our list. In fact, it’s both an environmentally conscious and economical choice: it has the lowest gallons-per-flush value – 1.1 GPF – and a very affordable price upon purchase. It also comes with the best warranty out of all of our recommendations, with a 5-year warranty on parts and a lifetime warranty on the china. The Toto Eco Drake toilet may be a bit more comfortable as it features an elongated bowl, but the American Standard’s round bowl makes it ideal for smaller, cramped bathrooms.

Choosing the Best Cheap Toilet for Your Home

Now that we’ve gone over the best options under $200, here are the most important factors that you should keep in mind while choosing the perfect fit for your bathroom.

Consider Your Budget

All of our recommendations are budget-friendly, but they still do vary in price. The price range of our recommendations is $100-$160. The Toto is the most expensive option, with a price of about $160. The Mansfield is at the bottom of the price range – with a low price of about $100. The American Standard is in the middle, costing approximately $130. 

“The price range of our recommendations is $100-$160.”

Keep in mind also that the water usage over time will affect your budget via water bills (1). The American Standard and the Toto waste less water than the Mansfield, so they may be more budget-friendly over time.

Water Efficiency

Water efficiency is important for both your wallet and the environment. The American Standard has the most water-efficient flush on our list, with a 1.1 GPF. The Toto is the second most eco-friendly option, with 1.28 GPF. The Mansfield spends more water, like most classical toilets, with a 1.6 GPF value. 

“Water efficiency is important for both your wallet and the environment.”

While the more water-efficient options feature flushing technologies that ensure a clean flush while wasting less water, you won’t always get the best effects as you would with a more wasteful option, like the Mansfield. In the end, though, it seems like a small price to pay for the huge difference you’d be making for the environment!

The shape of the Toilet Bowl

“While elongated bowls are generally more comfortable, round toilet bowls take up less space.”

Toilets feature either elongated or round bowls. While elongated bowls are generally more comfortable, ergonomic, and a preferred choice for people with disabilities, they do generally take up more space. Round toilet bowls are a better choice for smaller bathrooms, as they take up less space.

What’s Next?

We hope that our top picks and buying guide were useful in your search for finding the best toilet under $200! At the very least, we hope that we gave you a better idea of how to find a cheap toilet which is both durable and comfortable. To get more information about each of our recommended products, follow the title links to learn their price, in-depth specifications, and read some customer reviews.

While we have you, be sure to read our best toilet reviews, so that you can find the model that’s just right for your bathroom.

Scroll to Top